
Stop trying to make self-punishment work as a trauma recovery strategy.
It doesn’t.
And you’re not the first trauma survivor who’s going to make it work.
You’re DEFINITELY not the first trauma survivor to TRY to make it work.
We trauma survivors really love that idea— that we’re going to punish ourselves into feeling and functioning better.
Of course we love it. Punishment is very frequently how our behavior was “managed” growing up.
Many of our most formative experiences revolved around punishment— and not just at home, either.
My father was a dangerous, addicted, narcissistic man, and many of my damaging early experiences involved him— but many of them also revolved around peer group bullying I experienced for years (and years), primarily at school.
Abuse at home— physical, verbal, and emotional— and bullying at school are punishing experiences. They’re painful experiences, inflicted by someone else, that shape our behavior.
And even when we’ve left those experiences behind, we often pick right up where our abusers and bullies left off, in trying to shape our own behavior via punishment.
Maybe it’s what we feel we “deserve.”
Often it’s what we feel we “need.”
We just cannot imagine a world in which any force other than pain or threats or humiliation shapes our behavior.
Many survivors reading this truly think the only way we realistically manage or adjust our behavior is through shame, pressure, or humiliation.
Understand: it’s not our fault we think this.
We’re just doing what we know. We’re using the “tool” we have, that was programmed into us.
The truth about punishment, at least from a behavioral science perspective, is actually pretty well-established: punishment does not change behavior. Not long term.
If punishment reliably changed behavior, crime recidivism rates would be very different— but they’re not.
There are two was punishment DOES change behavior: it makes people sneaky about behavior they’re not “supposed” to do; and it makes people resent whatever entity is dishing out the punishment.
So what happens when we’re the ones punishing ourselves?
It means “parts” of us get “sneaky”— that is to say, we’re way more vulnerable to dissociatively “hiding” things from ourselves.
It also means we come to resent ourselves.
Does that sound like a combination that is supportive of trauma recovery?
I understand: the urge to punish ourselves can be strong. I struggle with it, especially when my behavior falls short of my values and goals.
But we need to resist.
Self-punishment is a distraction from our goals. It’s a layer of stress and self-conflict we don’t need and we can’t afford in trauma recovery.
Quit trying to make it work just because it’s familiar.
Breathe; blink; focus.









